Al-hakim Al-mustadrak Vol. 4 P. 398 «AUTHENTIC – WORKFLOW»

Furthermore, the presence of certain narrations on page 398 reveals the popular religious concerns of al-Hakim’s era (4th-5th century AH). This was a time when Shi’i Fatimid propaganda was rising, and various theological sects—Mu’tazila, Ash’arites, and traditionalist Hanbalis—were fiercely debating the nature of God and the status of the Companions. By including traditions about the virtues of Abu Bakr, Umar, and Uthman on pages like 398, al-Hakim was making a deliberate theological statement reinforcing Sunni orthodoxy against Shi’i critiques. Similarly, a hadith about intercession ( shafa’ah ) or seeing God in the Hereafter ( ru’yah ) would directly counter Mu’tazili denials. Thus, the page is not neutral; it is a battlefield where creedal lines are drawn through chains of transmission.

That vol. 4, p. 398 is identical in all prints. Truth: The page number shifts slightly between the Hyderabad (first edition) and the modern Beirut reprints. When citing, always specify the edition. al-hakim al-mustadrak vol. 4 p. 398

Page 398 frequently touches on Fitan (trials) and Malahim (epic battles). Modern researchers dealing with contemporary apocalyptic literature often trace the chain ( isnad ) of specific end-times narrations back to this exact page. If the chain is broken or contains a known liar (as flagged by al-Dhahabi), the entire theological argument collapses. Furthermore, the presence of certain narrations on page

Umm Salama kept that soil in a glass bottle, watching it faithfully. On the 10th of Muharram, 61 A.H., she saw the miraculous transformation. This narration, also supported by scholars like al-Dhahabi Similarly, a hadith about intercession ( shafa’ah )